Why ChatGPT Can’t Be Your HR Manager

Sally Dillon • February 26, 2025

Introduction

AI is making its way into every corner of business - including HR. But can you really replace HR expertise with ChatGPT?

I put it to the test.


I Asked ChatGPT "How to Deal with an Employee Issue?"... Yikes.


Yesterday, someone asked me:

"Why do small and medium businesses need HR help when they can just ask ChatGPT how to deal with an employee issue?"


Fair question. So, I went home, opened ChatGPT, and typed in:

💬 "How to deal with an employee issue?"


Here’s what it told me:

"Dealing with employee issues can be challenging, but it's important to approach the situation carefully. Start by gathering information about the issue to understand what’s going on. Then speak to the employee and use your best judgment to determine the best course of action."


Sounds… fine?


But it leaves out everything that actually matters..........


The Costly Pitfalls of AI-Generated HR Advice


Here’s what ChatGPT DIDN'T tell me - and what could cost businesses THOUSANDS in legal fees, fines, or reputational damage:

🚨 Not all issues can be handled informally: A “quick chat” isn’t enough for serious complaints.

🚨 Policies & laws matter: You need to follow company procedures and legal requirements.

🚨 Some situations require a formal investigation: It’s not just a judgment call.

🚨 Procedural fairness is a must: Meaning proper notice, transparency, and giving employees a chance to respond.

🚨 Surprise disciplinary meetings are a bad idea: Advance notice is key.

🚨 Employees have legal rights: Like having a support person present in serious discussions.

🚨 Instant terminations are risky: You cannot fire someone on the spot unless there’s clear serious misconduct (fraud, violence, etc.).

🚨 Bringing up past performance issues that were never discussed? Huge no-no.



HR Stands for Human Resources


AI doesn’t understand the nuances of human dynamics, behaviour, or the complexities that come with being human in the workplace. It can process data, but it lacks the emotional intelligence and contextual awareness required for ethical and legally sound HR decision-making.


Real Business Consequences


I’ve already seen real businesses make costly mistakes by trusting AI blindly.


🚩 Pay Rate Disaster: Someone asked ChatGPT for pay rates… and didn’t check them. Turns out, the rates didn’t exist - they were completely made up. Six months later, they engaged me for a payroll audit and had six months of back pay to fix, plus had to have an embarrassing and damaging conversation with their staff. Luckily, there were no Fair Work complaints before we caught the issue.


🚩 A $1.5M Mistake: A mishandled dismissal cost one business $1.5M after an employee successfully claimed psychological injury from an unfair process.


🚩 Contract Chaos: ChatGPT can generate employment contracts, but it doesn’t know the specific legal requirements for your industry. One business relied on ChatGPT for a restraint of trade clause, only to find out it wasn’t enforceable - allowing a key employee to leave and take clients with them.


🚩 Bonus Blunders: AI-generated advice on bonuses, commissions, and entitlements often misses legal nuances, leading to underpayment claims and disputes.


🚩 Workplace Investigations Gone Wrong: ChatGPT won’t tell you when you need to escalate an issue. I’ve seen businesses rely on basic AI advice for serious matters like harassment claims, failing to conduct a proper investigation - resulting in legal action and reputational damage.


AI isn’t intentionally misleading - it’s just not legally responsible  for the advice it gives. But you are.


Can AI help with HR? Yes - But Not Like This!


AI can be an amazing tool for HR - just not for high-stakes employee issues. The key is knowing where it helps and where you still need expert guidance.

AI can help with: Automating administrative HR tasks, drafting position descriptions (with human review), and streamlining workflows.


AI shouldn’t replace: Expert advice for legal matters, disciplinary processes, workplace investigations, and complex contract terms.

That’s why we’ve created resources to help businesses use AI the right way—without falling into costly legal traps. If you want guidance on leveraging AI safely in HR, plus tools to protect your business, check out HRmony Hub for expert support, templates, and training.


💡 Want to learn more?  Get in touch, and let’s chat about the right HR solutions for your business.



Final Thoughts


AI is a game-changer, but it’s not a legal expert, and it doesn’t have your back in court. Before you trust it with your business decisions, ask yourself:

👉 Would I be comfortable standing behind this advice in front of a lawyer or Commissioner?

👉 Have I checked the actual policies, laws, or awards that apply to my business?

👉 Do I fully understand the risks of getting it wrong?

If the answer isn’t a confident yes, it’s time to get the right support.



Need more help?

Reach out today for a consultation or utilise our free resources tailored to support your business.

  • Click here to book a FREE 30 minute consultation to discuss your HR challenges.
  • Click here to get a Business Health Check to review your policies, procedures and frameworks.
  • Click here to join our mailing list to get more free tips, advice and updates on all things HR, WHS and Leadership.
By Sally Dillon January 29, 2025
Introduction HR is one of the most misunderstood roles in business. Some believe HR exists to protect employees. Others think HR’s sole job is to defend the company. Both are wrong. And this misunderstanding is costing businesses money, trust, and talent. For over two decades, I’ve seen organisations sideline HR - treating them as a policy enforcer or an afterthought. The result? 🚨 Employees don’t trust HR. 🚨 Leaders fail to leverage HR strategically. 🚨 Businesses struggle with culture, retention, and performance. But here’s the truth: HR isn’t about sides. It’s about solutions. Great HR drives business outcomes by balancing people and performance. The question is: Are you using HR to its full potential? HR as a Strategic Powerhouse, Not Just a Policy Enforcer The best businesses don’t just "have" an HR department. They embed HR into leadership decisions. HR isn’t just about hiring, firing, and compliance - it’s about: ✅ Shaping culture and engagement (which directly impacts performance). ✅ Developing leadership capabilities (to create stronger teams). ✅ Driving strategic workforce planning (so you have the right people, in the right roles, at the right time). ✅ Maximising financial impact - because people are both your biggest cost and your greatest asset. If your HR function isn’t influencing leadership, growth, and profitability , you're leaving money on the table. HR as a Key Voice on Your Leadership Team Many leadership teams still treat HR as a support function rather than a core business driver. That’s a mistake. Your Chief People Officer (CPO) or HR Director should have the same level of influence as your CFO, COO, or Head of Sales. Why? Because your people strategy IS your business strategy. 🔹 You wouldn’t make financial decisions without consulting your CFO. 🔹 You wouldn’t make operational changes without your COO’s input. 🔹 So why make leadership and talent decisions without HR at the table ? And yet, in many businesses, HR reports to finance, operations, or admin - departments that have their own agenda when it comes to assessing people needs, budgets, and workforce requirements. HR should report directly to the CEO, or Business Owner to ensure people strategy is aligned with business strategy - not just budget constraints or operational efficiency. Because when HR is filtered through another department’s lens, critical workforce decisions become secondary to financial targets, logistical priorities, or admin processes. If your HR leader doesn’t report directly to the top, you may be unknowingly limiting their ability to drive real business outcomes. Are You Using HR to Its Full Potential? Take a moment and ask yourself: ❓ If you have an in-house HR team, are you using their skills and expertise across all areas of your business? Or are they stuck in admin-heavy tasks, when they could be driving strategic initiatives? ❓ If you’re a small or medium business and don’t have in-house HR, why haven’t you partnered with an external consultant? What’s stopping you from leveraging the expertise that could transform your business? In larger businesses, HR should go beyond just ‘HR.’ Under an expanded People & Culture framework, HR should oversee: ✔ Training & Development – ensuring leaders and employees are constantly upskilling. ✔ Work Health & Safety – making compliance, risk management, and employee wellbeing a priority. ✔ Recruitment & Talent Strategy – not just filling roles but attracting and retaining top performers. ✔ Major Projects & Change Management – ensuring workforce alignment with organisational shifts. In smaller businesses , these functions can be outsourced or strategically managed by an external HR consultant working directly with the business owner. This ensures a strong, aligned people strategy, while certain operational roles (finance, admin, or operations) may take on specific HR tasks - as long as they receive the right training, support, and strategic direction. HR isn’t just a department - it’s an investment in your business’s future. Whether in-house or external, make sure your HR function is working at a strategic level, not just buried in paperwork. HR’s Impact on the Bottom Line People aren’t just a cost centre - they are a profit driver. 📊 Labour is often one of the largest expenses in a business - so managing it strategically impacts profitability. 📊 Engaged employees are 23% more profitable , according to Gallup. 📊 Turnover costs 50-200% of an employee’s salary - losing top talent is expensive. When HR has a strategic voice in leadership , businesses see: ✔ Stronger alignment between business goals and people strategy. ✔ Faster, smarter hiring that supports growth. ✔ Better leadership development , reducing costly turnover. ✔ More effective workforce planning , so salaries, training, and hiring are investments—not wasted costs. Final Thought: HR is Not a Department - It’s a Business Growth Lever If your HR function feels like a compliance department , you’re doing it wrong. HR should be a leadership asset , helping your business make smarter, people-focused decisions. So, here’s my challenge to you: 📌 If you’re a CEO or MD - bring HR into the strategy conversation early and often. 📌 If you’re a leader - use HR as a coaching and development resource, not just a policy checker or problem fixer. 📌 If you’re in HR - push for a strategic role in leadership, not just operational support. Because when HR and leadership align , businesses don’t just succeed. They thrive. Want to Develop Stronger, More Strategic Leaders? If you’re serious about building leadership capability in your business, let’s talk. My Leadership Dynamics Accellerator Program helps CEOs, Business Owners, Leaders and HR teams create high-performing leaders who know how to balance people and performance. 📅 Book a free leadership triage call to see how we can help here . 🚀 Save your spot in our next Leadership Dynamics Accelerator Program here . 📩 Send us an email for more information here . Let’s build something stronger - together.
By Sally Dillon January 16, 2025
Introduction
By Sally Dillon October 4, 2024
Introduction
By Sally Dillon September 18, 2024
Introduction
By Sally Dillon September 16, 2024
Introduction
By Sally Dillon July 4, 2024
Is The Monkey Still Relevant? In the world of modern management, the concept of "Management Time: Who’s Got the Monkey?" by William Oncken Jr. and Donald L. Wass still resonates deeply. Originally published in 1974 and revisited multiple times, this seminal article sheds light on a perennial issue: managers overwhelmed by tasks while subordinates seem to have ample time and energy. Understanding Management Time Today Managers today face a quartet of time demands: Boss-imposed time: Tasks directly mandated by superiors, non-negotiable and swiftly penalised if neglected. System-imposed time: Requests from peers for support, vital for organisational harmony and efficiency. Self-imposed time: Initiatives and tasks originating from the manager themselves, including tasks delegated by subordinates. Team member-imposed time: Requests, questions, or tasks initiated by team members that require the manager's attention or input. The challenge lies in balancing these demands to maximise discretionary time—time not governed by external pressures and crucial for strategic decision-making. The Monkey Metaphor in Today’s Workplace Imagine a manager walking down the hallway, stopped by a subordinate with an urgent issue. Initially, the problem is the subordinate's ("the monkey is on their back"). However, as the manager engages without immediately resolving, the monkey leaps to the manager's back. This shift represents how subordinates can inadvertently burden managers with their tasks and decisions. Practical Leadership Takeaways Empowerment through Initiative: Managers should foster a culture where subordinates take initiative and responsibility. This not only lightens the manager’s load but also enhances team autonomy and morale. Clear Communication: Setting clear boundaries and expectations prevents monkeys from leaping onto the manager's back. Discussions should clarify who owns the next steps and when they should be completed. Time Management: Effective time management is not just about personal efficiency but about strategically using discretionary time to focus on high-impact tasks and strategic priorities. Implementing Modern Strategies Today's managers must proactively manage their time and responsibilities: Appointment-Based Support: Engage with subordinates by appointment rather than ad-hoc interruptions to manage tasks effectively. Documentation and Follow-Up: Use technology and structured communication tools to document tasks and progress, ensuring clarity and accountability without burdening the manager. Training and Empowerment: Invest in training programs that empower subordinates to handle tasks independently and make informed decisions. Conclusion The timeless lesson from "Management Time: Who’s Got the Monkey?" remains clear: managers must reclaim control over their time by preventing subordinate tasks from becoming their own. By fostering initiative, setting clear boundaries, and leveraging technology, modern leaders can achieve greater efficiency and effectiveness in their roles. This approach not only reduces stress but also enhances organisational productivity and employee satisfaction—a win-win for managers navigating today’s complex business environments. You can read the original HBR Article here. Further Enhance Your Leadership Skills If you find yourself grappling with the challenges of balancing managerial responsibilities and empowering your team effectively, consider exploring our Leadership Dynamics Program at Revolution Consulting Group. Designed to equip leaders with modern strategies and practical tools, our program focuses on fostering a culture of accountability, enhancing team dynamics, and maximising leadership potential. Whether you're looking to refine your leadership approach or empower your team to take on greater responsibilities, our tailored coaching and training solutions can support your journey towards becoming a more effective and influential leader. Click here to book an free Triage Call to find out about how our 12 week Leadership Dynamics Program can benefit you. Click here to join our mailing list to get more tips, advice and updates on all things HR and Leadership.
More Posts

READY TO GET THINGS DONE?

Revolution Consulting Group is your Dedicated HR Partner

Share by: